Recent litigation surrounding the Administration’s tariff authorities has materially increased legal and operational uncertainty for importers, manufacturers and downstream industrial sectors. The central issue is no longer whether tariffs remain a tool this Administration views as indispensable in its efforts to reorient the global trading system, but rather which statutory authorities can withstand judicial scrutiny and how companies should position themselves as the legal landscape evolves.
The most significant judicial development remains the U.S. Supreme Court’s February 2026 decision holding that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) does not authorize the President to impose tariffs. Learning Resources Inc. v. Trump invalidated the Administration’s emergency tariff framework and effectively eliminated IEEPA as a viable tariff authority going forward.
In response to the Supreme Court’s ruling on tariffs justified under IEEPA, the Administration swiftly shifted to alternative statutory authorities, including Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974, alongside potential reliance on Sections 301 and 232. The Administration imposed a temporary 10% global tariff under Section 122, arguing that persistent trade deficits constituted a qualifying balance-of-payments concern. That position has now come under substantial judicial pressure.
Last week, the U.S. Court of International Trade ruled in the combined cases of The State of Oregon v. United States and Burlap and Barrel, Inc. v. United States that the Administration’s Section 122 tariffs were unlawful, finding that the statute did not authorize the broad tariff action at issue. The court concluded that the Administration’s interpretation would effectively permit unlimited tariff authority untethered from the statute’s intended purpose.
However, the legal situation remains highly fluid. On May 12, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued an administrative stay allowing the tariffs to remain in effect while the appeal proceeds, giving both sides two weeks to provide additional information in support of their positions. As a practical matter, companies should assume tariffs continue to apply unless and until there is a final appellate ruling or formal Customs guidance suspending collection.
For industry, several practical implications are emerging:
- Tariff exposure is becoming increasingly litigation-driven rather than policy-driven.
- Refund opportunities may expand materially depending on how courts apply relief.
- Customs compliance and protest strategy have now become strategically important financial tools, not merely administrative functions.
- The Administration is likely to continue shifting toward more proven and durable tariff authorities, such as Section 301 and Section 232, if broader authorities are constrained by the courts.
Companies should recognize that courts have thus far largely limited remedies to named plaintiffs initially rather than issuing universal nationwide relief. That distinction is critically important. Following the Supreme Court decision on IEEPA tariffs, the lower Court of International Trade determined the relief granted applied to all importers of record.
From an operational standpoint, companies should consider several immediate actions:
- Conduct a tariff exposure audit
Companies should quantify duties paid under IEEPA Section 122 and any overlapping tariff programs since 2025, including identifying impacted HTS classifications, entry dates, brokers and liquidation status. - Identify eligible refunds
Importers should evaluate protests, post-summary corrections, reliquidation opportunities and potential litigation participation. - Review customs broker role and ACE access readiness
Many refund and reliquidation processes are moving through ACE-based workflows. Companies lacking direct visibility into their broker’s filings or ACE access may face operational delays. - Reassess sourcing and pricing assumptions
Companies should avoid assuming tariffs will disappear entirely. The more likely scenario is continued migration toward narrower, more legally defensible tariff programs. - Monitor Section 301 and Section 232 developments closely
The Administration is increasingly relying on sector-specific national security and unfair trade remedy authorities, particularly in semiconductors, advanced manufacturing, machinery, critical minerals and industrial technology.
The key takeaway for executives is that tariff strategy can no longer be viewed solely as a trade policy issue. It is now simultaneously a litigation issue, a customs administration issue, a cash-flow issue and a supply chain governance issue. Companies that actively manage their tariff data and maintain flexible sourcing and customs strategies will likely be significantly better positioned than companies waiting for definitive judicial resolution.
If you have any questions about how the Bose Public Affairs Group Trade team can support you as you navigate the quickly evolving trade landscape affecting your business, please call John Cooney at (202) 349-2303 or email him at jcooney@bosepublicaffairs.com.

John Cooney is senior vice president of governmental relations at Bose Public Affairs Group, based in the firm’s Washington, D.C., office. John has extensive international experience in the semiconductor sector, having served as a vice president of a global industry association connecting 1.5 million professionals from across the semiconductor, electronics design and manufacturing supply chain sectors. John has also spent more than 20 years in public policy and government relations and has a proven record of shaping advocacy strategies and advancing client priorities at all levels of government.
Bose Public Affairs Group is a fully integrated public affairs firm dedicated to successfully navigating clients through the many pathways of political, legislative, regulatory, communications and media environments.
Recent Comments